It’s beginning to look a lot like winter: Between Solitude and Socialising
“And don’t think the garden loses its ecstasy in winter.It’s quiet, but the roots are down there riotous.”
— attributed to Rumi

November has a public relations problem. October gets the autumn colour; December gets the fairy lights. November gets wet leaves, bare branches and the feeling that someone has turned the lights off before we’re ready.
The garden is looking decidedly less impressive. Stems collapse. Leaves gather in corners. Things that were flourishing a few weeks ago have apparently given up. There is a temptation to tidy everything away, preferably before anyone sees it.
We can be much the same with ourselves.
A quieter spell arrives. We feel less sociable, less full of ideas, less inclined to launch ourselves enthusiastically into whatever comes next. Almost immediately, we begin wondering what’s wrong. Shouldn’t we be doing something? Making plans? Getting out more?
Must everything that goes quiet be forced back to life?
We tend to recognise growth when it produces something we can see. A flower, a qualification, a finished piece of work. Something to show for our efforts. Waiting is harder to account for, especially when we don’t know what we’re waiting for.
Yet a bare tree is hardly doing November badly. Deciduous trees have already formed many of the buds that will open in spring. Beneath fallen leaves, decomposition continues. The garden’s activity has changed, although it offers rather less for Instagram.
We can accept this in the garden and still struggle to allow ourselves the same pause. Rest, we’re told, will make us more productive. Take a break so you can come back stronger. Even doing nothing must apparently justify itself by improving our performance later.
Can we have an afternoon off without making it an investment?
There are times when we need to withdraw from demands, including the demand to explain ourselves. We may have spent months being available, responding, organising, holding things together. Eventually, the prospect of another perfectly pleasant conversation can feel like another burden.
A restorative retreat might be a weekend away. It might equally be an hour with a book and the phone in another room. Part of the relief is being able to decide, for a while, what we give our attention to.
Solitude gives us room to discover what our own company is like when nobody needs anything from us. That can be restful. It can also be surprisingly uncomfortable. Once the conversation stops, we may hear the argument we’ve been having with ourselves.
In Solitude: A Return to the Self, Anthony Storr writes:
“All human beings need interests as well as relationships.”
It is a modest sentence, but it challenges the assumption that a satisfying life must be measured chiefly by the quality of our relationships. Reading, walking, making something, following an idea: these have a place of their own. We do not always need another person present for an experience to matter.
But retreat, solitude and isolation can look remarkably similar from the outside. A person sitting alone by a window might be enjoying a rare moment’s peace or wondering whether anybody remembers they exist.
I was just listening to Nick Drake’s Time of No Reply. It catches something of the melancholy of November: “Summer was gone and the heat died down.” As the song unfolds, the quiet becomes more troubling. Other people pass by; the singer remains alone. To my ear, it catches that uncertainty between wanting to be left in peace and wanting someone to notice we are there. We may need fewer demands without wanting to disappear from other people’s lives.
Choice matters, although it doesn’t explain everything. We may choose to stay home because we need rest, or because going out has begun to feel frightening. We may long for company and find ourselves unable to answer a text message when it comes.
Perhaps it helps to notice what happens during the time alone. Does some curiosity return? Can we enjoy a meal, become absorbed in a book, notice the birds making a tremendous fuss over very little? Or does the world feel increasingly distant, with every unanswered invitation making the next one harder?
It isn’t always easy to tell. Solitude can be uncomfortable and still worthwhile. Company can be exhausting and still welcome. Sometimes we need someone who will sit beside us without requiring a report on how we are getting on.
And what happens in our dreams while we are being quiet?
A dream might take us into an empty house, a winter field or a room where someone is sleeping. We can be very quick to decide that emptiness means deprivation, darkness means danger, and the sleeper ought to wake up. But how does the place feel? Is the empty room abandoned, or is it somewhere we can finally hear ourselves think? Is the sleeping figure exhausted? Safe? Waiting?
The dreamer’s feelings and associations matter. A locked door may offer protection to one person and imprisonment to another.
We might also notice our urge to interfere. Why must we open the door, fill the room, wake the sleeper? What is so difficult about allowing something to remain undisturbed?
Of course, the long, dark evenings are not welcome to everyone. There is nothing particularly restorative about being alone when we desperately want company. Nor do we have to keep withdrawing simply because the season provides a convenient metaphor.
Still, some quiet periods deserve a little patience before we set about correcting them. We may be tired. We may be grieving an ending we haven’t quite acknowledged. An old enthusiasm may have gone, while no new one has yet appeared.
It is tempting to hurry into that gap with a plan.
For now, perhaps the more useful question is whether we want company, need rest, or simply haven’t allowed ourselves enough time to find out.





Comments